There are only two aspects of songwriting that I thoroughly dislike: writing lyrics and writing music. As much as I love songwriting I just really hate writing songs.
Songwriting has always felt to me like sitting down to learn a cover tune that you’ve never heard before. Does it go to an F chord here or an A minor? I have no idea. I’ve never heard it.
The thing I like most about writing songs is listening to the very first demo. That’s where most of the enjoyment comes from for me. It’s rare for me to get more pleasure from listening to a finished recording than from listening to the first demo. That’s probably why I like posting my demos. But what you hear in my demos and what I hear are (I’m learning) two very different things.
As a basefall fan I would rather watch a major league pitcher with a 12-8 record than I would watch a nineteen year old, single-A, minor league pitcher who doesn’t have a change-up, can’t always locate his fastball, and can’t really throw his slider for strikes but is the guy that the scouts are drooling over because he has so much ability and potential.
Does that metaphor even work? In songwriting I’m a scout, not a fan.
Hearing a rough demo for me reveals the truth about whether or not the song, at its most basic core, works. Is the note choice correct? Is the melody memorable even with the distracting “nah, nah, nahs” in the abscence of lyrics? Is the emotional content there even without lyrics? Does the song have momentum? These are the things I’m listening for and it’s a very exciting thing when all of the answers are “yes”. In fact, for me, it is the most exciting moment in the birth of a song.
I remember hearing Spielberg say that if a movie is well-made, a person should be able to watch it with the sound turned down and still understand what is going on. I think my demos are an attempt to check for the same sort of thing in my songs. Does the song still work with only a guitar and a vocal consisting of random syllables?
I have five new songs that I’ve written since the new band was formed. Only one of those has the lyrics completed. I decided that instead of just charging forward to write more incomplete songs, I should put down the guitar and pick up the pen and get down to the dirty work of writing lyrics, which is what I’ve been doing lately.
Picking up the pen always feels like slamming on the creative brakes for me because the progress always slows to a crawl when it comes time to write lyrics. But writing and recording new demos for half-finished songs isn’t really progress either, it’s just piling up the work and putting off the inevitable drudgery of playing the lyricist. In fact, writing this post right now is just another way of dodging my notebook. If I can make this post long enough, then I will have to go straight to bed instead of writing lyrics.
Mission accomplished.
Recent Comments
I was just thinking about you yesterday wondering what you'v...
Ew. (yer funny)....
Dig you, miss you, can't wait to hear these new, best-ever s...
Partial to the sax - as always....
Totally understand... why do I need to play this piano piece...